9.12.22 Getting Jobs Market Back into Balance
Federal Reserve Chairman Jay Powell reiterated his warning that getting inflation under control will require some pain. Powell is likely making these warnings based on the arcane, clunky relationship between inflation and unemployment. The key to getting the market back into balance is a bigger labor force, and the economy is starting to experience a larger labor force as individuals come off the sidelines and rejoin the job market.
“Painful” Rise in Unemployment?
Members of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) recently issued warnings that the path to lower inflation will be painful. The crux of that view is based on the arcane, clunky Phillips Curve, which illustrates the relationship between inflation and unemployment. Like many concepts in global markets, the Phillips Curve went through many iterations and has plenty of versions. Nonetheless, the FOMC believes that the basic Phillips Curve concept is paramount for this current environment; i.e., the economy cannot get back to a long-run 2% inflation rate unless unemployment rises. And a future rise in unemployment could be significant and pain-provoking, especially for lower income households.
Is Current Inflation Driven by a Tight Labor Market?
The global economy is complex, and a simplification of reality always introduces distortions, so perhaps we should zoom out a bit. The world experienced multiple industrial revolutions, from mechanical to electrical to digital, and some talk about a fourth industrial revolution. Wherever the world is in its revolutionary phase, most agree that inflationary contributors change over time. And sometimes that change can happen quickly. We believe current inflation is a result of large fiscal stimulus during the COVID-19 shutdowns and nagging supply bottlenecks, further aggravated by a host of potential workers who are still on the sidelines.
The latest jobs report gave some glimmer of hope. Over a third of those unemployed and looking for work were previously not in the labor force as shown in Figure 1. As more individuals reenter the workforce, the labor market could loosen organically, especially as individuals currently not in the labor force move directly into a job.
People Are Generally Fully Employed
There are many nuances within the labor market. Some metrics reverted to pre-pandemic levels while others are still making new records, including the share of unemployed individuals who just reentered the workforce. Since job openings remain elevated, those who wish to work full time are doing so as shown in Figure 2. Since last year, the number of part timers who would prefer a full time job is steadily declining. Therefore, most of those looking for full time work get what they want.
Cautionary Tales Told by High Temp Help Services
The temporary help services industry tends to be a leading indicator for aggregate employment trends in the U.S. During emerging periods of expansion, temp help workers tend to be the first hired because of the relatively low cost to employers for benefits and training. Likewise, during periods of economic slowdown, temporary workers are typically the first to get the notorious pink slip.
In August, the economy has the highest ratio of temporary help workers since the data series began in the early 1990s [Figure 3]. Perhaps this could become one area of potential pain.
The inflation fight will be slow and painful, but will the pain be as acute as some suggest? We think the decline in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) from 9% to 6% will be much easier than the drop from 6% to sub-3%, partially because base effects will play a larger role and supply chains are improving. And at the core, we expect to see more people come off the sidelines and directly reenter the workforce, loosening the labor market without a significant spike in unemployment. One risk is the high number of workers in temporary help services since these jobs often are the first to go during times of economic uncertainty. Another risk is a Federal Reserve (Fed) who may not have the luxury to wait and see how the front-loaded rates hikes earlier this year will affect the real economy. For now, the Fed will be committed to additional front-loaded rate hikes, increasing the risks of recession next year.
- Important Disclosures
- This material is for general information only and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual.There is no assurance that the view s or strategies discussed are suitable for all investors or will yield positive outcomes. Investing involves risks including possible loss of principal.Any economic forecasts set forth maynot developas predicted and are subject to change.
- References to markets,asset classes, and sectors are generallyregarding the corresponding market index. Indexesare unmanagedstatistical compositesand cannot be invested intodirectly. Index performanceis not indicativeof the performance of any investmentand does not reflect fees, expenses, or sales charges. All performance referenced is historicaland is no guaranteeof future results.
- Any company namesnoted hereinare for educationalpurposes only and not an indicationof trading intentor a solicitationof their products or services. LPLFinancialdoesn’tprovide research on individualequities.
- All informationis believedto be from reliablesources; how ever, LPL Financialmakesno representationas to its completeness or accuracy.
- TheStandard & Poor’s500 Index (S&P500)is a capitalization-w eightedindex of 500 stocks designed to measureperformance of the broad domesticeconomythrough changes in the aggregate market value of 500 stocks representingall major industries.
- ThePEratio (price-to-earnings ratio) is a measureof the price paid for a share relativeto the annual net incomeor profit earned by the firm per share. It is a financial ratio used for valuation:a higherPE ratio meansthat investors are payingmore for each unit of net income,so the stock is more expensive comparedto one w ith low er PEratio.
- Earningsper share (EPS)is the portionof a company’sprofit allocatedto each outstandingshare of commonstock. EPS serves as an indicatorof a company’sprofitability.Earningsper share is generally considered to be the single mostimportant variablein determininga share’s price. It is also a major componentused to calculate the price-to-earnings valuationratio.
- All index data from FactSet.
- This research material has been prepared by LPL Financial LLC.
- Securities and adv isory services offered through LPL Financial (LPL), a registered inv estment advisor and broker-dealer (member FINRA/SIPC). Insurance products are offered through LPL or its licensed affiliates. To the extent you are receiving investment advice from a separately registered independent investment advisor that is not an LPL affiliate, please note LPL makes no representation with respect to such entity.
- Not Insured by FDIC/NCUA or Any Other Government Agency Not Bank/Credit Union Guaranteed Not Bank/Credit Union Deposits or Obligations May Lose Value
- Tracking # 1-05325027